What happens to neighborhoods after urban greening takes root? In the United States, over 26,000 miles of abandoned rail lines have been converted into trails, with another 9,000 miles underway. I use the geography of abandoned railroads to study how decades of rail trail openings have changed neighborhoods. In Greater Boston, where I observe trail opening dates, housing values rise by 7% within a decade of opening, alongside a 1.8 percentage point increase in the college-educated share and little change in other socioeconomic measures. By the second decade, housing values rise by 19%, the college-educated share by 7.7 points, and household incomes by 14%, suggesting that early compositional shifts amplify over time. Across all metropolitan areas, where I observe rail trails but not date of opening, I conduct a long-differences analysis. I instrument for trail creation using inefficiently connected historical rail segments, identified by edge betweenness centrality. Estimates show that between 1970 and 2020, tracts with rail trails experienced 18% higher housing value growth and similar patterns of sorting, along with a 24% increase in housing supply.