The
endangered land of Renter-World
by Nicolas
P. Retsinas
May 5, 2006
The Boston Globe
Welcome to Renter-World, home to more than 34 million
households. Renter-World denizens, aka tenants, comprise all ages.
Eighty percent of all twentysomething households rent; so do 4 million
senior households. Tenants come in all socioeconomic strata: Twenty
percent of renters earn more than $60,000 a year; another 20 percent
earn less than $10,000.
Yet
a myopic Uncle Sam barely sees Renter-World.
Instead,
Uncle Sam focuses on Owner-World. Owner-World captures the federal
tax breaks: The homeownership tax deductions for mortgage interest
and property taxes top $100 billion a year and are rising rapidly.
Owner-World
also captures the federal attention: For almost 100 years, starting
with a 1918 Department of Labor campaign and continuing through
Franklin Delano Roosevelt's New Deal, Bill Clinton's National Homeownership
Partnership, and George Bush's Ownership Society, the federal government
has been promoting homeownership. Today 69 percent of households
own a home -- an all-time high.
From
Uncle Sam's vantage, that statistic marks success. Homeownership
is the American "dream," the crucial first step on a family's
pathway to the middle class. A homeowner amasses equity, so that
one day he can own a piece of America. That vested interest spurs
involvement in schools, in neighborhoods, in political life. Just
as important, the home gives the owner a financial cushion. Even
if owners do not reap the windfall of a superheated market, the
home can still be a hedge against inflation.
Indeed,
we are a nation of immigrants who have marked the exodus with a
series of papers: green cards, citizenship, and mortgages. The ''American
dream" may be a three-bedroom Cape on a tiny lot, but immigrants
have come here for that dream.
So
Uncle Sam's myopia is understandable. He expects renters to move
on -- to become owners. That is what they too expect.
Renter-World,
however, is in trouble.
Even
though we are building new rental units, we are not adding to the
net ''affordable" (a euphemism for cheap) units. That supply
is shrinking. Between 1993 and 2003, we lost 2 million low-rent
units from the rental inventory. At the same time, rents are rising,
especially for newly constructed units.
Consider
the plight of the lowest-income renters: 70 percent pay more than
half their income for housing. The National Low Income Coalition
could not find one county in the United States where a minimum wage
worker, paying 30 percent of his or her income for housing, could
afford a one-bedroom apartment.
As
for the government rent-subsidies aimed at alleviating the hardship
of low-income tenants, those too have shrunk. The war on terror
and the war in Iraq have pushed them off the agenda.
Today
parts of Renter-World constitute a desperation sector of America.
Poor people, crammed into too-small apartments, struggle to pay
for food, rent, transportation, and medical care.
To
paraphrase Linda Loman, lamenting the plight of her husband, Willy,
in ''Death of a Salesman": ''Attention must be paid" to
these renters.
The
reason is pragmatic.
In
the past, Renter-World has been a gateway to Owner-World. Low-income
workers, renting for a few years, have saved up enough for the downpayment
on a house, and, with scrimping, have kept up with mortgage payments.
But today's renters cannot so easily make that leap. The Big Box
shelver, married to the fast food waitress, may want the American
dream. They may have left family thousands of miles away to seize
the dream. But without some housing relief, they will never leave
Renter-World.
And
the promise of America, the dream for millions of Americans, is
to leave Renter-World. That first mortgage -- often the first mortgage
for a family -- constitutes step one in the economic mobility we
value. High rents trap families, anchoring them on the bottom rung
of the ladder that we want them to climb.
For
the sake of the renters, and of the nation as a whole, Uncle Sam
must pay attention to Renter-World.
Nicolas
P. Retsinas is director of the Joint Center for Housing Studies
at Harvard University.
|