Looking at the double-digit rise in home prices
in the Boston area in recent years, buyers may be right to wonder
if their money is being well invested. Is your home really worth
what you've paid for it? And more to the point, when it is time
for you to sell will you recoup what you've spent?
When housing prices are bid up purely under the
expectation that they will continue to appreciate, that creates
a price bubble. When prices fall precipitously and houses sell for
below what an owner paid, that's a burst bubble. Any homeowner who's
been caught in the descent knows the experience is most unpleasant.
Given our unsteady economy and the sharp decline
in stock prices, you might wonder if the real estate market is sound.
Are we in the middle of a bubble, and if so, when will it burst?In the Boston area, anxiety might be even greater.
As recently as a decade ago, anyone living within commuting distance
of Boston Common heard the very distinct "pop" of a housing
bubble bursting.
Think back to the go-go years of the 1980s, when
the high-tech economy was soaring and eager homeowners were snapping
up high-priced homes. From 1980 to 1989, according to the Freddie
Mac repeat sales index, housing prices in the Boston area nearly
tripled.
But the boom was short lived; technology companies
slashed jobs, the federal government slashed defense contracts,
and home builders slashed construction jobs. From the peak in 1989
to the trough in 1992, home prices slid by 8 percent. Adjusting
for general price inflation, home prices fell fully 25 percent in
six years. Might that very same scenario repeat itself today? Are
home prices headed for another nosedive?
Given today's rather different set of economic circumstances,
I doubt it. Barring a far more significant economic downturn in
our region than we have seen, home price appreciation is more likely
to slow than turn negative.
Remarkable though it seems, this recent price run
up has been far more contained than the last. In the 1980s, home
prices grew by more than 20 percent in each of three consecutive
years and by 27 percent in one year alone. In contrast, during the
1990s, in no year did home prices grow by more than 16 percent.
Income growth, meanwhile, was stronger. During the 1980s, according
to the US Census Bureau, median family income in Massachusetts grew
by about 25 percent, but in the 1990s it grew by 39 percent.
The conditions that precipitated the tumble of house
prices in the early 1990s, however, explain why the past boom-bust
cycle is less likely to repeat itself. Back then, people thought
the high-tech expansion was permanent and that prices would continue
to go up. When that sector faltered, it intersected with a broader
national recession. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics,
unemployment in the state rose from 2.6 percent in December 1987
to 9.8 percent in March 1991. Reeling, unemployed workers could
not find work, and their savings were depleted.
Overbuilding in the mid-1980s also contributed to
the bust. Building permits issued from 1984 through 1987 averaged
about 35,000 per year in Massachusetts. According to a study by
Boston Fed economist Lynn Browne, building in New England outpaced
demand more than in any other region in the 1980s.In the end, what caused the 1980s bubble to form
was a sense that home prices would continue to increase, and what
caused it to burst was the strain that overbuilding and heavy job
losses placed on housing markets. Unemployed workers put a glut
of existing homes on the market but there were not enough employed
workers to buy them.
Thankfully, this time around the region has been
spared the crippling job losses and chronic overbuilding. The unemployment
rate likely peaked at 6.1 percent in March of this year. Housing
permits over the past several years have been running at about half
the average number built annually from 1984 to 1987.
And unlike last time, people are buying homes more
cautiously. In addition, they are buying for reasons that make good
economic sense: Interest rates have been coming down, and their
incomes have been going up. When prices began to fall in Massachusetts
in the late 1980s, interest rates hovered around 10 percent. Now
they stand under 6 percent - a 40-year low. Lower interest rates
have helped reduce monthly mortgage payments in the face of higher
home prices. Add the limited amount of home building in the state
and the conditions remain favorable for sustainable home prices.
If, as most economists believe, we are moving into
a more complete recovery rather than sliding back into a recession,
home prices are more likely to slow than turn negative. Should interest
rates rise sharply, home buyers can offset increases by shifting
to adjustable lower-rate mortgages with shorter terms. Others who
might consider moving may elect to stay put rather than buying with
a higher-rate mortgage. This could slow sales but also limit the
supply of homes for sale, thus helping support prices.
Spending more for housing relative to income to
live in Massachusetts is nothing new. People are willing to devote
larger shares of their income to live here because - in the language
of economists - they feel doing so "maximizes their utility."
Could home prices fall here again? Of course, but
it will take a more severe local recession or greater overbuilding
than we have seen so far to force them down.